KnowBrainer Speech Recognition
Decrease font size
Increase font size
Topic Title: Using speech with PostBox email program?
Topic Summary: eg SAPI, speech commands (Dragon, KnowBrainer, ...)
Created On: 05/31/2021 10:58 PM
Status: Post and Reply
Linear : Threading : Single : Branch
 Using speech with PostBox email program?   - Ag - 05/31/2021 10:58 PM  
 Using speech with PostBox email program?   - Alan Cantor - 06/01/2021 10:26 AM  
 Using speech with PostBox email program?   - Lunis Orcutt - 06/01/2021 10:50 AM  
 05/31/2021 10:58 PM
User is offline View Users Profile Print this message

Author Icon
Top-Tier Member

Posts: 647
Joined: 07/08/2019

BRIEF: I appreciate any reports, good or bad, using the postbox email program with speech recognition. Particularly in comparison to Thunderbird, Outlook, or Gmail web interface.


I suppose I should also ask questions about generic PostBox features such as handling Gmail labels, version control of search folders, etc.


(Mention of other email options also appreciated, although please let's not hijack this thread overmuch away from PostBox. if there is a lot of discussion about alternatives to Outlook/Thunderbird/PostBox, let's start a new thread.)




It is time for me to make yet another attempt to improve my toolchain. In particular, email.  Since I restarted using speech recognition, my email efficiency has been much lower than it was when I was typing and mousing all the time.


When I restarted using speech recognition, at first I tried using Outlook, and then quickly switched to using Thunderbird.  My email server remains Gmail, both personal and work.



---+ Why Not Outlook?


Outlook seems to be the most widely recommended email program used via speech recognition. As one might hope for a Microsoft application[*], Outlook is almost completely speech aware.


(Note *: I could only wish that Microsoft OneNote were equally speech ready.)


Unfortunately, as I have noted elsewhere Outlook produces HTML email that is often unreadable by many of the people I interact with - some of whom are using Gmail on the web, some other UNIX-ish email programs. I want to continue using HTML email, not have to fall back to using plaintext, but I also want to interact with these people.


Furthermore, I make extensive use of search folders and email classification rules, and I think that it is very important to be able to version control and diff these things. Standard Outlook does not support that. I have purchased Sperry Software's Power Rules Manager (, which allows rules to be version controlled.  Since search folders are very similar to rules, I am surprised they are not supported, but they aren't :-(


Outlook interfaces to Gmail via IMAP, and has the usual problems handling Gmail labels (mis)interpreted as IMAP folders.



---+ Thunderbird issues 


Probably the biggest issue with Thunderbird is that one has this itchy feeling that it is on the verge of being orphaned. Also, recent versions of Thunderbird have broken compatibility with many of the add-ins that were historically attractive.


The main reasons I have been using Thunderbird had been (a) it produces HTML email that everybody I correspond with can read, unlike Outlook, and (b) I can version control its saved folders and rules.  Plus (c) lots of plug-ins, some of which I have been able to modify to better suit my needs.


My main reason to consider leaving Thunderbird is how poorly Thunderbird/IMAP's folders interact with Gmail labels.   Thunderbird and IMAP only really understand a message being in one folder at a time, whereas in Gmail a message can have multiple labels at the same time.    I really want to have queries of the form

      in:Inbox AND (from:mailing-list-foo OR label:Foo OR label:Fubar)

but as far as I can tell there is no way of doing this, since Gmail labels map to IMAP folders, and a message can only be in one folder at any time.  Gmail messages with multiple labels appear in multiple folders, but Thunderbird/IMAP does not understand this. 


However, Outlook has the same limitation.  PostBox is reported to handle Gmail labels better.





---+ Q: is PostBox a better email program?

PostBox,, is a commercial email program, $40 lifetime. Windows on Mac. Apparently not mobile phones, that's probably OK for me, since I have learned the hard way that thumb typing on mobile phones is a big cause of my computeritis. 


PostBox says "Postbox supports Gmail or GSuite labels and matches much of the organizational behavior of Google accounts online."  As far as I can tell it only means hits handling delete in a semi-reasonable manner. There is no evidence that it can understand the message having multiple labels in its queries.  (this may be something I just need to test manually, but I have been disappointed so often ...)

 All Mail and Important folders are also supported.


---+ Speech control of Outlook, Thunderbird, PostBox, and ...

As mentioned above, Outlook probably has the best speech control.


I have been using Thunderbird for a year or so, and have a fairly good set of speech commands.


Most important, I have a methodology that allows me to fairly quickly create the command sets I need for a new application. So I doubt that postbox will be a very big problem. Unless... its menu navigation shortcuts are highly highly highly context specific, and AutoHotKey cannot detect the context by looking at window titles or control names.


Outlook of course has full Select-and-Say control for correcting dictation. Thunderbird does not, and I suspect neither does the PostBox app.  However, DragonCapture helps a lot, and I hope that I can use an approach similar to what Vocola's author provided - allowing select interaction within a window of recent commands, emulated using backspace. (Darn, I cannot find the post that described this...)  (I also hope that Rudiger implements this in DragonCapture before I get around to doing it myself - though I was well on my way before I learned that Vocola had already implemented something like this.)  (Or, using Edgar's approach of vacuuming stuff out of a text box into something like Notepad, editing there using Select-and-Say, and then blowing it back into the text box.)


---+ bottom line Q:


I can see that several people posting on this form have used the PostBox app.


Q: how good is it with respect to speech control "naked" adding nothing? E.g. raw navigation of menus?


Q: are its menu structures amenable to speech control by emulating keystrokes?   


Q: context sensitivity...


Q: And generic email goodness, such as interaction with Gmail labels




DPG15.6 (also DPI 15.3) + KB, Sennheiser MB Pro 1 UC ML, BTD 800 dongle, Windows 10 Pro, MS Surface Book 3, Intel Core i7-1065G7 CPU @ 1.3/1.5GHz (4 cores, 8 logical, GPU=NVIDIA Quadro RTX 3000 with Max-Q Design.

32177 users are registered to the KnowBrainer Speech Recognition forum.
There are currently 1 users logged in.
The most users ever online was 12124 on 09/09/2020 at 04:59 AM.
There are currently 434 guests browsing this forum, which makes a total of 435 users using this forum.

FuseTalk Standard Edition v4.0 - © 1999-2021 FuseTalk™ Inc. All rights reserved.